clawdbot/docs/refactor/strict-config.md

summary, read_when

summary	read_when
Strict config validation + doctor-only migrations	Designing or implementing config validation behavior Working on config migrations or doctor workflows Handling plugin config schemas or plugin load gating

Strict config validation (doctor-only migrations)

Goals

• Reject unknown config keys everywhere (root + nested).
• Reject plugin config without a schema; don’t load that plugin.
• Remove legacy auto-migration on load; migrations run via doctor only.
• Auto-run doctor (dry-run) on startup; if invalid, block non-diagnostic commands.

Non-goals

• Backward compatibility on load (legacy keys do not auto-migrate).
• Silent drops of unrecognized keys.

Strict validation rules

• Config must match the schema exactly at every level.
• Unknown keys are validation errors (no passthrough at root or nested).
• plugins.entries.<id>.config must be validated by the plugin’s schema.
  • If a plugin lacks a schema, reject plugin load and surface a clear error.
• Unknown channels.<id> keys are errors unless a plugin manifest declares the channel id.
• Plugin manifests (clawdbot.plugin.json) are required for all plugins.

Plugin schema enforcement

• Each plugin provides a strict JSON Schema for its config (inline in the manifest).
• Plugin load flow:
  1. Resolve plugin manifest + schema (clawdbot.plugin.json).
  2. Validate config against the schema.
  3. If missing schema or invalid config: block plugin load, record error.
• Error message includes:
  • Plugin id
  • Reason (missing schema / invalid config)
  • Path(s) that failed validation
• Disabled plugins keep their config, but Doctor + logs surface a warning.

Doctor flow

• Doctor runs every time config is loaded (dry-run by default).
• If config invalid:
  • Print a summary + actionable errors.
  • Instruct: clawdbot doctor --fix.
• clawdbot doctor --fix:
  • Applies migrations.
  • Removes unknown keys.
  • Writes updated config.

Command gating (when config is invalid)

Allowed (diagnostic-only):

• clawdbot doctor
• clawdbot logs
• clawdbot health
• clawdbot help
• clawdbot status
• clawdbot daemon

Everything else must hard-fail with: “Config invalid. Run clawdbot doctor --fix.”

Error UX format

• Single summary header.
• Grouped sections:
  • Unknown keys (full paths)
  • Legacy keys / migrations needed
  • Plugin load failures (plugin id + reason + path)

Implementation touchpoints

• src/config/zod-schema.ts: remove root passthrough; strict objects everywhere.
• src/config/zod-schema.providers.ts: ensure strict channel schemas.
• src/config/validation.ts: fail on unknown keys; do not apply legacy migrations.
• src/config/io.ts: remove legacy auto-migrations; always run doctor dry-run.
• src/config/legacy*.ts: move usage to doctor only.
• src/plugins/*: add schema registry + gating.
• CLI command gating in src/cli.

Tests

• Unknown key rejection (root + nested).
• Plugin missing schema → plugin load blocked with clear error.
• Invalid config → gateway startup blocked except diagnostic commands.
• Doctor dry-run auto; doctor --fix writes corrected config.